Grizzlies in the mist

Grizzly Man
Grizzly Man
$9.99 @ Amazon »

Average customer rating: 3.5

The most disturbing movie I've seen in the last six months (that isn't Saw) has to be Grizzly Man. Tim Treadwell, the grizzly man in the title, dedicated himself to "protecting" bears in the Alaskan peninsula. After 13 years of living with bears every summer, he died in the fall of 2003. He was eaten by a hungry bear, which is not at all a spoiler.

The movie is largely Treadwell's own video from past expeditions right up until a few hours before his death. The audio of the bear attack on Treadwell and his girlfriend was captured by his camera (but thankfully not played). Werner Herzog, who compiled Treadwell's video, narrates the film with a kind of curious affection.

What makes Treadwell interesting is his sense of purpose about studying and protecting bears coupled with a shallow, narcissistic creepiness. I'm sure he had a genuine love of bears, but he also depends on them for an identity (not unlike that other amateur grizzly enthusiast Troy Hurtubise).

Treadwell styles himself as the bears' last line of defense, but it's hard to tell if his amateur Crocodile Hunter schtick is somehow noble or just a self-constructed vanity reality. Probably both, and swinging toward the latter.

But aside from Treadwell's weird and troubled personality, there's the landscape and the bears. The landscape is stark and beautiful (I really love alpine/sub-alpine terrain). The bears are amazing, and it's remarkable that Treadwell could live so close to them for so long. I saw a grizzly from a couple of hundred feet last year, and that's as close as I want to get.

Worth a rental.

Comments

This is a brilliant film. I heard Herzog on FreshAir before it came out, and even though he pretty much described the film and his perspective on the nature of nature, and the story, and his choices as a filmmaker, it was still brilliant and fresh to see it. Might be worth chasing down the audio of Herzog on FreshAir at npr.org - I'd say it was last fall, maybe October or November?

I've since become a huge fan of Herzog, at least conceptually - there was a really interesting profile of him in a very recent New Yorker that gave a lot of insight about his overall approach to his work, which is very intense and very insane and very passionate. I feel like understanding Herzog gives a bit more depth into Grizzly Man.

There were some interesting ethnographic moments in the film - I actually brought it in to the class I was teaching just to show the students one bit. In the scene where the medical examiner is returning the watch, Herzog (the presumed camera operator) is basically just hanging back and letting this almost scripted interaction take place. And after it ends, the people sort of seem confused as if actors where their script has run out and they don't know what to do. Herzog keeps filming. And then he moves in. And it's an awkward pause, cut already, go to the next shot, why did you leave this in. And then he moves in to the woman further and she looks up and sobs "this is all I've got left." It's a really powerful moment that MAKES the scene that he got by simply letting there be silence.

Posted on May 23, 2006
Gene says...

Thanks Steve. Here's the interview with Werner Herzog on NPR.

One of the interesting threads that runs through the film is the relationship betweeen Herzog and Treadwell as filmmakers. There are a couple of times where Herzog's narration seems to focus on Treadwell as an artist and not a flaky amateur conservationist.

And the medical examiner... he was really strange. In the scene you mention he seems to be acting, but he's completely stiff. On the other hand his description of Treadwell's death is intense and quite terrifying (and Herzog shot that scene brilliantly).

Posted on May 24, 2006

Post a comment

Remember me?

Basic HTML is allowed.

 

About this Page

Posted by Gene Smith on May 23, 2006. Before this there was links for 2006-05-20. Next up is links for 2006-05-24.

About the Author

Gene Smith is a principal with nForm, one of Canada's leading user experience consulting firms. He writes about information architecture, interaction design, community, the web and other such topics. More >

Subscribe

Get the feed Get the RSS feed (full posts, no ads)

My Book

Recent Posts

Archives

Elsewhere

You can also find me on Flickr, Upcoming, LinkedIn, Del.icio.us and Digg.

Work

nForm User Experience

Endorsements

Hosting by Dreamhost.