Story of a (missed) photo opportunity

'Twelve-year-old Shane Bowman plays with his old heart in Edmonton, Canada on Friday, July 11, 2003. Bowman had a heart transplant and got a chance to see his old heart to have some closure on his illness. Bowman had dialated cardiomyopathy, a condition caused by a virus, and his heart was enlarged to about 555 grams. A normal heart is about 200 grams. (AP Photo/CP/Edmonton Sun, Perry Mah)'My friend Anne is the media coordinator for our local children's hospital. She organized the photo op for the picture at right, a 12-year old heart transplant patient with his old, enlarged heart. Our major local paper, the Edmonton Journal, declined the photo op. I don't know why--I guess they thought a boy holding his own heart wouldn't make a good news photo.

Anyway, the Edmonton Sun (the other paper) took this picture, it was carried on the wire and picked up by something like 1200 media outlets around the world. It's one of the most emailed photos on Yahoo!. Here's the caption: "Twelve-year-old Shane Bowman plays with his old heart in Edmonton, Canada on Friday, July 11, 2003. Bowman had a heart transplant and got a chance to see his old heart to have some closure on his illness. Bowman had dialated cardiomyopathy, a condition caused by a virus, and his heart was enlarged to about 555 grams. A normal heart is about 200 grams. (AP Photo/CP/Edmonton Sun, Perry Mah)"

Some editor at the Journal is kicking himself for missing this one.

Comments

Alan says...

Gene,
An excellent example of the capriciousness inherent to any judgement about what is or isn't news. I would be very interested in knowing why the Journal editor elected not to use the photo. The whole topic of how the media decides what is newsworthy is extremely fascinating.

Good reporters are often said to possess a "nose for news". --Is this an instance of someone with little such "nose" (in the same way that Winnie the Pooh is characterized as a bear of very little brain), or just more heartless journalism from the Edmonton Journal?

I really like your blog Gene.

Posted on Jul 18, 2003
Shane Bowman says...

Hey everyone guess who this is? It's Shane Bowman no joke! I'm 13 now and in school i thought it was cool that i found myself on google!

Posted on Oct 4, 2004
Shane Bowman says...

I'm at skool (LOOK SLANG) HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA DYlan's here too and Drew I'm gunna make this message board come to life OH YAH!!!

Posted on Oct 5, 2004
Gene says...

Hey Shane. Great to hear from you (and I'm glad you're doing well). But now I'm turning off the comments. ;)

Posted on Oct 8, 2004

 

About this Page

Posted by Gene Smith on Jul 18, 2003. Before this there was Clueless PR. Next up is Charlottetown, PEI photos.

About the Author

Gene Smith is a principal with nForm, one of Canada's leading user experience consulting firms. He writes about information architecture, interaction design, community, the web and other such topics. More >

Subscribe

Get the feed Get the RSS feed (full posts, no ads)

My Book

Recent Posts

Archives

Elsewhere

You can also find me on Flickr, Upcoming, LinkedIn, Del.icio.us and Digg.

Work

nForm User Experience

Endorsements

Hosting by Dreamhost.